Yesterday, my wife and I took our girls to see Kenneth Branagh's version of Cinderella. While I am not going to be bragging here about the quality of the movie, I thought it was admittedly quite entertaining and well made, to say the least, although none of the actors are unknown to me, except Cate Blanchett who interpreted the role of the stepmother with her classic style. The visual effects obviously help add up to the magic they are due to showcase to children.
The fairy tale is so classic that you may remember every single twist of it. However, as a parent, I found one troubling fact about the movie, particularly knowing that my kids were there watching.
Nearly all the leading and supporting characters in the movie has a line to say "Have courage and be kind". And they say it over and over. With the latter ("be kind"), I simply have no issue. I bet it's in every parent's advisory book to their children.
Yet, the "have courage" part is what I intrigued me the most. It does not seem to resonate with the way Cinderella handles her domestic abuse from her stepmother and stepsisters. As the main character who is supposedly a role model for every girl, she does not reflect the girl power, defiance, courage nor boldness, unlike Elsa or Anna in Frozen or Merida in Brave.
At one point in the movie, I started to get excited when Cinderella showed a slight courage to challenge her stepmother when they were having an argument over the glass shoe. I thought we would see some unexpected twist of the story. But my hope was cut too short. Shortly, we were reminded again how submissive Cinderella was after her stepmother locked her in inside the attic. She just gave in.
To her defense though, she says it clearly that she does it all for the sake of keeping her promise to her parents to cherish the house they love. This, I agree! Keeping a promise is a lesson that our kids can learn.
Cinderella is fragile and unfortunately irrelevant. Being kind does not always have to be tame or subdued. Being kind does not always mean you have to suffer to make people happy. Being kind does not mean you have to give in your courage.
After all, the movie is rated PG. As parents, it is our responsibility to remain critical and to teach our kids about the values in life.
These are my viewpoints. Feel free to read, scan, digest, smile, laugh, cry, agree or disagree. But don't sweat it!
Showing posts with label Movie. Show all posts
Showing posts with label Movie. Show all posts
Sunday, March 22, 2015
Saturday, January 05, 2008
Persepolis: Iran According to a (former) Iranian
An autobiography of Marjane Satrapi, whom I call a liberal Iranian woman (now lives in Paris), in a graphical black and white novel.In fact, I was introduced to this book first in 2004 when I visited Karim, my best friend, in Beirut. He strongly recommended it. But I did not bother to buy them until it was recently adapted to an animated movie early last year (directed by Marjane herself and Vincent Parronaud). It immediately received a huge success in France, critically acclaimed and awared le prix de jury at the prestigious Cannes Film Festival last year. Now, it is on its way trying its luck at this year's Oscar.
I personally found the book interesting (Dita gave it to me as my birthday present). Whilst reading it, my mind drifted back to the years 2003-2005 during which I traveled quite frequently between Dubai and different parts of Iran for my recruiting job. I visited the universities and colleges in different towns and met a lot of Iranians. Although I never really lived in there, but my regular visits in the past allowed me to learn about their rich cultures, the people, the history and a little bit of politics. When I read Persepolis, it felt like I was having a deja vue. I feel like someone else has already told me a similar tale about Iran before. Yes,everything is similar to what I saw and heard back then. The black veils, the 'guardians', the satellite dish story, the underground party and so forth. In fact, I now have a few good friends from Iran.
During my visit, I always felt sorry for the people out there and for the current social and economical situations there. Persia used to be an extremely rich and well respected country. People lived in a good standard of living. They are rich of natural resources, including oil, but the classic question is "where has the money gone?" The gap between the rich and the pool is extremely huge! (You will find the rich Iranians investing in The Palm Dubai or living in LA. They even have a Persian tv channel over there! Many migrated to Canada or Scandinavia.)
Wandering around Iran, you feel like you are in the 60's. The infrastructure, the vehicles... how they look obsolete. Old local manufactured cars dominate the polutted streets. But you can still see old models of Peugeot or Citroen quite often. Many Japanese, Korean and French products benefit from the US embargo policy.
First impression about the people: they are very welcoming, although within the two-year time span I had a few bad impressions with some of them (I don't blame them for being too prejudice though). As I said, I have now some nice and warm-hearted Iranian friends. Once they know you well, they will respect the relationships.
Now, back to the book. In fact, Persepolis has nothing to do with its content. The setting was mainly in Tehran (and Vienna). Persepolis is the ancient name of Shiraz (historically famous for the wine) which I have visited once. Incredible Romanian ruins and some tombs of the Persian kings. Amongst the Iranian cities, I like Esfahan most. Very rich of cultures with some picturesque bridges.
The book is extremely entertaining with a lot of irony about the suppressed life in Iran. Marjane, an art graduate, has a unique way of storytelling through the black and white graphics. I then learned how comics can be the most effective way to convey a biography, particularly that of someone unheard of before, like Marjane). The only thing I do not agree is the way she depicts God in the book (I think she's way too liberal on this).
After finishing the book, we watched the dvd only last week. Like many books that were brought into big screens, most are disapppointing. Persepolis is unexceptional. Even though I admire the unique animation (the graphics are better than those in the book), 85 minutes seem a bit too short to convey every single thing from the book. As a result, you will find several parts have intentionally been omitted. Those who never read the book before perhaps will find it rather confusing.
Nevertheless, Persepolis is a breakthrough for animation movies, autobiographies and the people of Iran, although I personally doubt the movie itself will ever openly be out at cinemas in Iran. Apparently, Marjane seems more optimistic. She cited in one of the interviews that the people in Iran will find a way to watch her movie, even if it means to get it through a black market (as usual... like all banned Western music or movies).
Un chapeau pour Marjane Satrapi (a heavy smoker with a mole on her nose)! Bonne chance a Oscar!
You can find two inspiring interviews with Marjane here and here.
Tuesday, May 15, 2007
Borat, The Queen, Chris Gardner and Ms Sunshine
I have just recently watched those 4 movies on DVD. Outdated, as some of you may say. The truth is I have not been to a cinema for a while. The last time was for Mel Gibson's Apocalypto. These are my personal reviews on those 4 movies with which you may or may not agree.
Borat... it's simply an overhype! Maybe I put my expectation too high prior to watching it, having read the reviews and the fact that it won the Golden Globe (am I correct?). I thought I was going to see a Michael Moore type of movie or a superbly hilarious movie at the least. Frankly, I was only laughing for the first 5 minutes. I watched the rest with some wrinkles on my forehead. I was disappointed and simply disgusted with the screenplay. The dialogues are so indecent! The script is too vulgar with a tendency to cheap and cheesy sex jokes. (Borat, be mature! If he could have ever made it more thoughtful, I think it would have been much better and enjoyable.) The scene I hated most was when he and Azamat were wrestling naked. Only one word can describe it: disgusting! It forced me to fast forward to the next scene. Needless to say, the DVD is now in the trash bin.
The Queen... I enjoyed Helen Mirren's performance here. Like many non-British audience, it was the first time I heard about her. In fact, in this movie, she succeeded in creating that royal character. Not an easy job to do, I guess. As a result, one can see "the Queen" throughout the movie. Brilliant acting! Well deserving for all the awards. Regardless whether or not the whole story is true, it is always interesting to see the life of a royal family. No matter how hard the Queen was trying to hide her feelings, the movie reminds us all that at the end of the day she is only human.
The Pursuit of Happyness... (No, it's not a typo! Happyness with 'y', instead of 'i'). For some people, it may be a simple drama inspired by the past life of Chris Gardner. But to me personally, there is a lot of lessons learned out of it . The fact that I always like movies based on true stories made it easier for me to enjoy and digest it. To me, it's more than just a short excerpt of Mr. Gardner's biography on how he struggled to be successful in his past personal and professional life (he is now the owner of an investment company and a sought-after motivational speaker in the US). As a father, I was touched by his strong determination and commitment to be a good father (and a good husband) even when he was broke. Trying to put myself on his shoes, I bet it was not an easy job. If the movie pictured him right, as an individual person, the guy has a full swing of the integrated character ethics in him and undoubtedly he deserves what he earns now.
Little Miss Sunshine... I would give 2.5 out of 5. Lightweight drama, in my humble opinion. A little too Hollywood. However, I must admit the screenplay is different. The author successfully developed a simple story to describe different characters in that movie. The ending is unexpected, though rather flat. Still, it's enjoyable.
Borat... it's simply an overhype! Maybe I put my expectation too high prior to watching it, having read the reviews and the fact that it won the Golden Globe (am I correct?). I thought I was going to see a Michael Moore type of movie or a superbly hilarious movie at the least. Frankly, I was only laughing for the first 5 minutes. I watched the rest with some wrinkles on my forehead. I was disappointed and simply disgusted with the screenplay. The dialogues are so indecent! The script is too vulgar with a tendency to cheap and cheesy sex jokes. (Borat, be mature! If he could have ever made it more thoughtful, I think it would have been much better and enjoyable.) The scene I hated most was when he and Azamat were wrestling naked. Only one word can describe it: disgusting! It forced me to fast forward to the next scene. Needless to say, the DVD is now in the trash bin.
The Queen... I enjoyed Helen Mirren's performance here. Like many non-British audience, it was the first time I heard about her. In fact, in this movie, she succeeded in creating that royal character. Not an easy job to do, I guess. As a result, one can see "the Queen" throughout the movie. Brilliant acting! Well deserving for all the awards. Regardless whether or not the whole story is true, it is always interesting to see the life of a royal family. No matter how hard the Queen was trying to hide her feelings, the movie reminds us all that at the end of the day she is only human.
The Pursuit of Happyness... (No, it's not a typo! Happyness with 'y', instead of 'i'). For some people, it may be a simple drama inspired by the past life of Chris Gardner. But to me personally, there is a lot of lessons learned out of it . The fact that I always like movies based on true stories made it easier for me to enjoy and digest it. To me, it's more than just a short excerpt of Mr. Gardner's biography on how he struggled to be successful in his past personal and professional life (he is now the owner of an investment company and a sought-after motivational speaker in the US). As a father, I was touched by his strong determination and commitment to be a good father (and a good husband) even when he was broke. Trying to put myself on his shoes, I bet it was not an easy job. If the movie pictured him right, as an individual person, the guy has a full swing of the integrated character ethics in him and undoubtedly he deserves what he earns now.
Little Miss Sunshine... I would give 2.5 out of 5. Lightweight drama, in my humble opinion. A little too Hollywood. However, I must admit the screenplay is different. The author successfully developed a simple story to describe different characters in that movie. The ending is unexpected, though rather flat. Still, it's enjoyable.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)
